Sydney Sweeney’s latest campaign with American Eagle was supposed to be about charity. Instead, it turned into a full-on internet debate about wokeness, cleavage, and cancel culture.
The campaign, titled “Sydney Sweeney Has Great Jeans,” launched with a clear goal: sell $89 denim and donate 100% of the proceeds to Crisis Text Line, a mental health service supporting domestic violence survivors.
But things went sideways fast. In the promo video, Sweeney jokes about her “genes” as the camera pans to her chest, then quips, “Hey! Eyes up here.” That moment, meant to be cheeky, drew outrage online—with critics calling it “tone-deaf” and “grossly sexual” for such a serious cause.
The internet’s culture war battleground
Within hours, TikTok and Twitter/X became ground zero for dueling takes.
Some progressive users called it “textbook objectification,” while others insisted the backlash was rooted in puritanism. One viral clip stitched the ad with feminist commentary, accusing brands of using empowerment as a disguise for old-school tactics.
But the louder the outrage got, the more views—and defenders—the campaign gained. Sweeney’s fans labeled the uproar “performative” and “proof the woke mob’s losing grip.”
A Gen Z marketing gamble
American Eagle’s choice of Sweeney wasn’t accidental. She’s one of the few actresses with Gen Z cred and cross-political appeal—famous enough for fashion, relatable enough for memes.
The brand banked on her image as both bombshell and girl-next-door to ride the line between edgy and mainstream. Internally, sources say execs expected “a little noise,” but didn’t anticipate a culture war. The buzz, however, has only amplified the campaign’s reach, giving American Eagle a front-row seat in the authenticity Olympics.
Charity meets controversy
What started as a well-intentioned effort became another example of how quickly the internet can polarize anything.
Some viewers accused the ad of prioritizing sex appeal over substance. Others called out the absurdity of launching a campaign for domestic abuse survivors with a cleavage joke.
But fans pushed back just as hard.
To them, it wasn’t offensive—it was subversive. They saw Sweeney’s style and sass as a rejection of forced virtue-signaling. One viral post declared, “Woke advertising is dead. Sydney Sweeney killed it.”
Meme stock energy, real-world results
Amid the noise, American Eagle quietly celebrated.
The retailer’s stock jumped over 10% following the campaign, a rare win in a year of weak retail numbers. Analysts even floated the idea that it could join the “meme stock” club—brands driven more by buzz than balance sheets.
Behind the scenes, American Eagle executives are doubling down on Sweeney as their main star. It’s a strategic shift from multi-celeb campaigns to one bold, cultural bet. “She brings the allure,” said company president Jennifer Foyle, calling her the brand’s “biggest get yet.”
So, is this the future of marketing—glamour with purpose, controversy optional? If so, Sydney Sweeney just might be the face of it.
